I got confused, we are on a 392 Forum so I am assuming we are all talking about 392's. You are referring to a regular JL maybe Rubicon. to run the same 35 he could have run a 315 (same tire the Recon is getting) on a 7.5 rim which most all Jeep wheels are unless it is a low level sport, he didn't need a 2" Mopar lift he needed a leveling kit for $99-$149, you can fit a 315 on the standard spare tire carrier, maybe he needed the tailgate tire carrier upgrade at best or leave the stock spare and put a tire cover on it which many people do.
If he had a Rubicon he had a 3.73 or 4.10 so didn't need gears.
Read the Recon list carefully, it is a 1.5 lift and 315's which are shorter than a true 35 and narrower. The 392 has way more equipment, don't be fooled by the gear and tire and transfer case, sounds like the Power Wagon version of a Wrangler, very capable off road vehicle but that's a big gear that is going to get some terrible fuel economy on the highway.
If he had a sport he would want gears, the entire thing could have been done for less than half that if he had consulted the right people. Unless of course he wanted all new bling and not stock.
THATS A RECON PACKEDGE:
The new Jeep Wrangler Xtreme Recon Package includes:
• LT315/70R17C (35-inch) BF Goodrich KO2 All-Terrain Tires
• 17-inch x 8-inch Beadlock Capable Wheels
• 4.56:1 Axle Ratio
• 1.5-inch Factory Suspension Lift with uniquely tuned shocks
I bet you are getting the wheel below, a 1.5 vs 2 inch lift.