I checked out the Top Tier website. I'm going to call a measured amount of BS on it. Here's why:
- In my area, I buy gas at Casey's or Kum & Go because they carry ethanol free premium (In Oklahoma, you can only get 91 Octane without ethanol).
- Neither Casey's or Kum & Go are on the "Top Tier" brand list, but Quick Trip is among others like Conoco, Shell, Philips 66, none of which are near me in any way.
- Quick Trip does not have Ethanol Free Premium, not sure about the others but I suspect they don't either around here...
- In order to get the "Top Tier" cert and display it on your pumps, you have to pay a licensing fee, which adds to the cost per gallon.
- Quick Trip has pretty cheap gas, but again not ethanol free. so I can't see them having a higher quality fuel product at a lower price than the ethanol free premium I get at the stations that carry it.
In short, I suspect that the Top Tier website is set up to drive you to the stations that pay the licensing fees above all else. If the stations don't pay that fee, and therefore can't display that certification, it may not necessarily mean their fuel is sub standard... There may also be a component of this designed to drive people to fuels WITH ethanol...
Unless someone from a fuel blending and supply company can chime in to provide concrete evidence that the ethanol free non-top tier fuels are not as good as the ethanol blends, I'm sticking with ethanol free. Just my two cents.