I have a late '22 XR with SOT (came off the truck w/ several '23 392's and has the passenger side dingdong attached to the frame...happy it came with the "many bolt" trim rings) A big consideration for me would be...it is right.
My rig has had no issues ($#!+ am I messing with the gods or what

). A new one would have me going through the whole "hope it isn't a problem child" thing again.
I've had 4 Rubicons over time, 2 w/SOT. I enjoy the top BUT would not take a multi thousand dollar bath to get it.
Would like to have some of the "upgrades" of a '24 however they aren't must haves and I believe the mechanical stuff I'd want can be aftermarket mods later on.
When I force rank what really matters...I have one that was the right price, has all the options I wanted, and has the most important consideration...it has been a reliable tank of a rig.
Good luck with your decision...just make sure you have one!!!